CHICAGO (Nov. 14, 2026) — When Kofi Kingston and Xavier Woods stunned fans by brutally betraying Big E on WWE television, the shocking heel turn concluded a decade of celebrated brotherhood and set the stage for a darker, more ruthless chapter of The New Day. Behind the scenes, however, creative deliberations explored an even more explosive—and polarizing—scenario: drafting Ridge Holland into the group as their new third enforcer.
A Controversial Concept Rooted in Real-World History
As first reported by Dave Meltzer in the Wrestling Observer Newsletter and detailed by WrestleZone, WWE creative writers actively pitched pairing Holland with Kingston and Woods immediately after their turn on Big E. The intended goal was to generate searing television heat by leaning directly into the real-world trauma that altered Big E’s career.
"There was an idea when the New Day turned heel on Big E to have Ridge Holland as a third member of the New Day," Meltzer reported in the newsletter. "It was discussed and ultimately nixed."
The proposed pairing would have drawn upon the fateful March 11, 2022 episode of SmackDown in Birmingham, Alabama, where Big E suffered fractures to his C1 and C6 vertebrae following an overhead belly-to-belly suplex delivered by Holland outside the ring. While Big E made a full recovery in daily life and publicly maintained that he harbored zero animosity toward Holland, the severe injury permanently prevented him from receiving medical clearance to compete inside a wrestling ring.
Why WWE Management Opted for Restraint
While some within creative argued that introducing Holland would cement Kingston and Woods as irredeemable villains—effectively taunting Big E with the very performer involved in his career-ending accident—higher leadership recognized the immense risk of crossing from scripted drama into tasteless exploitation. WWE ultimately decided that exploiting legitimate, life-altering bodily trauma was unnecessary, particularly given the natural emotional resonance already generated by Kingston and Woods turning on their own brother.
Instead, Kingston and Woods have forged ahead as a ruthless two-man unit, stripping away the pancake-tossing whimsical antics of their past decade to focus on cold, calculated violence in the tag team division. Meanwhile, Holland has maintained his focus on WWE NXT and his ongoing storyline involvement with Chase U, avoiding an angle that could have burdened his character with uncomfortable real-world backlash.
Sources and Credits
Reporting sources: Backstage creative reporting by Dave Meltzer in the Wrestling Observer Newsletter, newsletter aggregation and analysis from WrestleZone, and storyline tracking via Cageside Seats.
Visuals: Section-calibrated PWSignal barbed-wire banner, masked wrestler sprite (male-crossed.png), accessible Rosemont arena location map (wwe-shelved-creative-pitch-ridge-holland-new-day-heel-turn-won-2026-map.svg), and interactive spotlight slides created by PWSignal (Illustration · PWSignal).

