REPORTING (Nov. 16, 2026) — Attorneys representing WWE star Marcel Barthel (Ludwig Kaiser) have filed a motion to subpoena comprehensive medical and billing records after alleged victim Richard Reap claimed he suffered a torn rotator cuff and a concussion during an April elevator altercation in Orlando.
Defense Demands Medical Records and Billing Statements
The misdemeanor battery prosecution against WWE Superstar Marcel Barthel—who competes on WWE television as Ludwig Kaiser and has simultaneously performed under the masked persona El Grande Americano—escalated with new evidentiary filings in the Ninth Judicial Circuit Court of Orange County, Florida.
According to court documents filed through the Orange County Clerk of Courts and analyzed by Fightful, the alleged victim in the case, Richard Reap, has asserted substantial physical injuries stemming from an altercation on April 23, 2026. Reap alleges that during a physical confrontation inside a hotel elevator, Barthel struck him, causing a torn rotator cuff and a concussion.
In response to these claims, Barthel's defense counsel filed a formal motion requesting court-authorized subpoenas directing Reap to surrender his complete medical documentation spanning from the date of the incident through November 12, 2026.
Motion Outlines Broad Discovery of Pre-Existing Conditions
The defense filing stresses that access to unredacted medical charts is indispensable to trial preparation and cross-examination. Barthel's legal team is seeking to determine whether Reap sought immediate medical treatment following the incident, whether diagnostic imaging confirms an acute tear versus degenerative wear, and whether subsequent physical activities or pre-existing ailments caused the claimed shoulder condition.
The motion specifically targets:
"Emergency department records, physician and nursing notes, diagnostic reports, imaging reports (including MRI and X-ray data), consultation records, discharge instructions, physical therapy referrals, and billing records from April 23, 2026, through November 12, 2026. The subpoena is limited to records concerning the alleged torn rotator cuff, concussion, head injury, shoulder injury, or other physical condition attributed to the charged incident."
In earlier court filings submitted in July 2026, Barthel pleaded not guilty to the single misdemeanor charge. His defense maintained that Barthel did not initiate physical contact, stating that Reap engaged in aggressive verbal heckling before positioning himself to block Barthel from exiting the elevator cab.
Court Calendar and Potential 2027 Trial Window
Under Florida criminal procedure, criminal defendants possess broad discovery rights to compel evidence that bears on alleged damages and witness credibility. A hearing on the subpoena request is slated to precede the upcoming pre-trial conference scheduled for December 17, 2026, before presiding Orange County circuit judges.
Should the state and defense fail to reach a pre-trial resolution, diversion program, or dismissal, the case will enter the judicial trial docket in January 2027. Throughout the proceedings, Barthel has remained an active featured competitor on WWE television alongside World Heavyweight Champion Gunther in Imperium.
Featured Figures in This Story
Sources and Credits
Reporting sources: Orange County Clerk of Courts and legal reporting by Fightful.
Visuals: Category-calibrated PWSignal barbed-wire banner in Breaking News red, masked wrestler sprite, interactive figures slideshow, and Orange County jurisdictional map (ludwig-kaiser-defense-subpoenas-medical-records-alleged-rotator-cuff-concussion-battery-case-2026-map.svg) created by PWSignal (Illustration · PWSignal).

