ORANGE COUNTY, Fla. (Nov. 13, 2026) — A defense subpoena motion filed November 12 in Orange County, Florida, discloses that alleged victim Richard Reap claims he suffered a concussion and torn rotator cuff during an April 23 altercation with WWE superstar Ludwig Kaiser.
Subpoena Motion Discloses Extent of Allegations Against Marcel Barthel
A new legal filing in the misdemeanor battery case against WWE superstar Ludwig Kaiser (real name Marcel Barthel, 34) has revealed the specific physical injuries alleged by complainant Richard Reap. According to court documents submitted on November 12, 2026, in the Ninth Judicial Circuit Court of Florida for Orange County, defense attorneys representing Barthel have formally moved for the issuance of a subpoena duces tecum directing Reap to produce complete medical records relating to treatment he received following the April 23, 2026 incident.
The motion, first reported by F4WOnline / Wrestling Observer, confirms that Reap is claiming he sustained a torn rotator cuff in his shoulder alongside a diagnosed concussion as a direct result of the physical encounter in downtown Orlando. Defense counsel argues that obtaining the underlying medical records, imaging scans, and physician evaluations is indispensable to assessing the medical plausibility, causation, and timeline of Reap's assertions ahead of trial proceedings.
The defense filing states that having unfettered access to these records is material to evaluating whether the alleged injuries were pre-existing, aggravated by unrelated activities, or directly attributable to the altercation. In criminal battery proceedings in Florida, the severity and documented proof of alleged bodily harm can directly influence sentencing parameters, trial strategy, and potential restitution claims.
Not Guilty Plea Entered as Misdemeanor Trial Approaches
Barthel has formally entered a plea of not guilty to the single count of misdemeanor battery. He is represented by private criminal defense counsel in Florida. Misdemeanor battery in Florida is classified as a first-degree misdemeanor under Florida Statute § 784.03, carrying potential statutory penalties of up to one year in county jail, probation, or monetary fines upon conviction.
Throughout the pendency of the legal proceedings, Kaiser has remained an active competitor on WWE's flagship broadcast, Monday Night Raw. He continues to perform as a cornerstone of the Imperium faction alongside reigning World Heavyweight Champion Gunther, maintaining prominent weekly television placement while his defense attorneys handle preliminary court hearings and discovery deadlines in Orlando.
In adherence to journalistic standards, an arrest or criminal filing represents an unproven accusation rather than a determination of liability or guilt. Barthel maintains the presumption of innocence under the law, and no trial date has yet been finalized as both parties proceed through pretrial evidentiary motions.
Sources and Credits
Reporting sources: Legal filings and reporting verified by F4WOnline / Wrestling Observer, with supplementary docket records from the Ninth Judicial Circuit Court of Florida (Orange County).
Visuals: Section-calibrated PWSignal barbed-wire banner, masked wrestler sprite (male-crossed.png), accessible SVG venue map, and four-slide featured personnel spotlight graphics created by PWSignal (Illustration · PWSignal).

