Latest
Talent News

Good Brothers Reveal Canyon Ceman Rejected PAC for 'Not Being Handsome Enough' Before WWE Walkout

On Talk 'n Shop, Doc Gallows and Karl Anderson recall an early WWE executive blunder that delayed PAC's signing and reveal PAC's blunt private declaration before walking out in 2017.

Read the story
Talent News · Read the story
PWSignal Talent News thumbnail reading 'GOOD BROTHERS REVEAL / CANYON CEMAN / REJECTED PAC OVER LOOKS' with gold bar 'TALK N SHOP REVEALS EXEC / BLUNDER AND 2017 EXIT' beside a gold masked wrestler sprite flexing with microphone.
Illustration · PWSignal
Share this story

STAMFORD, Conn. (Nov. 16, 2026) — In a revealing live recording of the Talk ’n Shop podcast, former WWE Raw Tag Team Champions Doc Gallows and Karl Anderson shared astonishing backstage stories about the late PAC, detailing how former WWE Senior Director of Talent Relations Canyon Ceman shockingly passed on signing the British high-flyer after an early tryout because he deemed him “not handsome enough.”

As documented by Eric Mutter of Wrestling Inc., the Good Brothers also pulled back the curtain on PAC’s abrupt 2017 walkout from WWE, recalling his private, profanity-laced determination to leave the promotion regardless of the financial uncertainty that existed prior to the launch of AEW.

PODCASTTalk 'n Shop Live
EXECUTIVE NAMEDCanyon Ceman (Talent Relations)
SUBJECTPAC / Adrian Neville

The Tryout That Stunned WWE Scouts

Gallows remembered PAC as a beloved colleague and an extraordinary athlete whose otherworldly high-flying repertoire had already gained legendary status across Dragon Gate in Japan and European independent promotions. However, during an early WWE evaluation camp years before his eventual 2012 NXT debut, WWE management made a baffling recruitment decision.

“He blew the tryout out of the water,” Gallows recounted. “And then we didn’t see him, and somebody goes, ‘Well, why didn’t they hire PAC?’ And they go, ‘Canyon Ceman said that he wasn’t handsome enough to be hired.’ I’m like, ‘This is professional wrestling.’ That’s when we were really questioning the people in charge at that time.”

Gallows lambasted the superficial critique, noting that Ceman’s short-sighted evaluation delayed a generational performer from reaching a global audience: “What a dumb decision. They could’ve had a hold of him even earlier, and you could’ve seen even more of him on a worldwide scale. But boy did he show everybody, just killing it in WWE, making his own decision to get out of there, and being such a staple of AEW.”

Key Figures in This Account 1 / 3
Podcast Hosts PWSignal spotlight card for The Good Brothers.

The Good Brothers

Doc Gallows and Karl Anderson shared untold stories on Talk 'n Shop about PAC's early WWE tryout.

Illustration · PWSignal

Canyon Ceman's Talent Relations Legacy

Canyon Ceman, a former professional beach volleyball player, oversaw WWE’s developmental talent scouting and Performance Center recruitment from 2012 until his departure from the company in 2021. While Ceman helped sign numerous collegiate athletes, his tenure faced recurrent criticism from veteran competitors who argued traditional wrestling intuition was often subordinated to cosmetic preferences.

PAC eventually signed with WWE in 2012, capturing the NXT Championship and the NXT Tag Team Championship before evolving into the dominant “King of the Cruiserweights” on 205 Live and Monday Night Raw.

PAC's 2017 Walkout and Taking the Risk

Despite his undeniable on-screen success, PAC grew profoundly disillusioned with WWE creative direction and pay-scale discrepancies in late 2017. Karl Anderson revealed that shortly before PAC walked out of a Raw taping in Indianapolis, the two had an eye-opening backstage exchange.

“He goes, ‘I can’t wait to get the f*** out of here,’” Anderson recalled. “I remember thinking, and I probably even said it to him, I was like, ‘Where the f***’s he going to go? What’s he going to do?’ But he did it. Most important is he had the balls to do it.”

At the time, walking away from WWE meant forfeiting steady guaranteed income, as the alternative domestic marketplace was severely constrained. PAC spent months sitting out his contract freeze before returning to Dragon Gate in Japan and subsequently signing with AEW in January 2019, cementing his reputation as a fearless pioneer who valued his creative integrity above all else.

Sources and Credits

Reporting sources: Wrestling Inc. (transcription and report by Eric Mutter, Nov. 15, 2026) and Talk ’n Shop live podcast recording with Doc Gallows and Karl Anderson.

Visuals: Category-calibrated PWSignal barbed-wire banner in Talent News gold, masked wrestler sprite (male-flex.png), microphone prop (microphone.png), accessible Stamford corporate location map (good-brothers-reveal-canyon-ceman-rejected-pac-talk-n-shop-2026-map.svg), and spotlight cards created by PWSignal (Illustration · PWSignal).